Wednesday, February 08, 2012

Halftime in America

Arguably (because there’s always an argument about it, as VW pointed out in their actual ad), the best ad of the Superbowl was the Clint Eastwood “Halftime in America” narrative for Chrysler, an ode to Detroit. It was very “Morning in America” Reagan-esque and very stirring. At least for some. I was actually more moved by a similar effort by Chrysler last year using a Chrysler 300 and an Eminem soundtrack.

This one, alternatively, annoyed me. It wasn’t the moody imagery, the obvious attempt at emotional manipulation, or the subtle insertion of exclusively Chrysler products to represent a revival of Detroit (it was their ad, after all). It was the choice of Clint Eastwood as spokes-icon.

Because weeks earlier, Clint had stated that GM and Chrysler should not have been bailed out. It is a position I agree with, incidentally, although likely for different reasons than Clint. But regardless of my politics, there was Clint, inspiring the citizenry with an inspiring, Dirty Harry voiced call to arms that dared me to disagree with him = that it was, in fact, halftime and an opportunity for America to renew itself in the ‘second half’. A second half that should never have occurred, per Clint.

This is not to say that I think it was a bad ad. Just... untrustworthy and lacking credibilty to anyone familiar with Eastwood's politics. Its an important message. A stirring message. It was also a bit of a whitewash given Clint’s values, something more akin to a political ad overlooking the candidate’s shortcomings. And it should be noted that at the half, the 'Patriots' already had the lead, came out in the second half and padded that lead, and then ultimately lost.

Indeed, its halftime, America.

UPDATE: Insincerity breeds contempt,and parody. I'm not alone in this, I guess. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_8qCbHsUA